Pineapple Cream Cheese Pie!
For as long as I can remember, over 60 years, this has been my favorite!
My mother was given this recipe by a good friend while serving as WAVES in the US Navy in World War II. It was Devra’s family recipe. Now, it’s historic.
All my life, “regular” cheesecake has seemed heavy and gummy and dry compared to this light and creamy delight. For over 20 years, this has been a special someone’s only birthday dessert.
It’s been one of my family’s favorites ever since WWII. That’s long enough to make it ours, too. The original recipe is handwritten in fountain pen in the front of my mother’s favorite cookbook. It simply lists the ingredients, and which go into the filling and which the topping. The details are mine.
Note: There are two crust options these days, since I am not the only person who feels better gluten free.
We make it in a standard 9″ pie pan. It’s a cream cheese pie, not a cheesecake.
Over the years, I have tried low fat and sugar-free variations, and they were awful. In the memory of the brave women who served in our military, one of whom shared this recipe with a fellow WAVE officer, or for the sake of historical accuracy, please make the filling with the old-time original ingredients that were available in the 1940s, real cream cheese and real (whole milk) sour cream. Save that chalky low fat for another recipe.
This pie is well worth a dietary sacrifice at another meal.
ORIGINAL (Graham) Crust
12-14 graham crackers, crumbled fine, OR 1-1/4 c packaged graham cracker crumbs
1/4 c melted butter
Mix together, pat into pan. I save 1/2 tsp to sprinkle on the top when it is all done.
GLUTEN FREE (Toasted Almond) Crust
1-1/4 c almond meal (I use Bob’s Red Mill, it’s coarser)
Few drops pure almond extract
1/4 c melted butter or coconut oil
Toast almond meal to the color of graham crackers. Reserve 1/2 tsp of toasted almond meal. Mix the remainder with melted butter or coconut oil, pat into pan.
FILLING
12 oz. (one large and one small Philadelphia Cream Cheese, the real, original stuff) Important, must be at ROOM TEMPERATURE
2 large eggs
3/4 c sugar (sometimes I use 1/2 c white with 1/4 c brown or palm sugar)
2 tsp real vanilla extract, I always use bourbon vanilla
1 small can crushed pineapple, drained and liquid reserved
TOPPING
8 oz. sour cream, the normal old-fashioned kind
3-1/2 Tbsp sugar
1 tsp vanilla
Juice drained from pineapple
(We mix the topping while the pie is baking, so the sugar dissolves nicely.)
ASSEMBLE PIE
Whip the room temperature cream cheese well. Add eggs one at a time, then sugar, vanilla, and well drained pineapple.
Pour into crust. Bake at 350 degrees till the center is just barely set. In my oven that’s 35 minutes, but your oven may be hotter or slower, so to be safe, check till it barely jiggles at all when the edge of the pie plate is tapped.
Cool 5 minutes.
Apply the topping evenly over the top, sprinkle on the reserved 1/2 tsp of pie crust material randomly on top, and bake 10 more minutes.
Cool on counter, then refrigerate at least 8 hours before serving (it makes a difference). This pie actually is capable of staying fresh for days and days in the refrigerator, but tastes much too good to last that long!
This recipe is very special to my family. If you try it, please post a comment, thanks!
Copyright 2015, Laurie B. Adams
You must be logged in to post a comment.